Justice: Opening Thoughts

“Every one should get what they deserve.”

If a teen studies, works hard, and succeeds in high school, then that teen should be allowed to go to college.

If a woman goes to work everyday, gives her best effort, and accomplishes the requirements of her job, then she should be able to provide for her family.

If a man doesn’t steal, doesn’t kill, and works to keep the law, then he should be able to live relatively free of legal trouble.

At the same time, if a man kills his neighbor, then he should go to jail.

If a woman robs a convenience store, she should be arrested.

If a teen cheats on a test, he should flunk.

“Everyone gets what they deserve.” This is our culturally informed understanding of “justice.” It stands on two pillars: merit and rights.

Merit is what an individual earns. It is not his from the start. It is something he obtains through effort.

It is just that the athlete is selected to play in the game, because he has worked harder than everyone else in practice during the week.

It is just that the doctor is paid a higher wage than the waiter, because the doctor first completed a decade of school before beginning his profession.

It is just that the valedictorian give a speech at graduation, because she studied harder than everyone else in her class.

We see things as just when someone has earned the reward.

Rights are what an individual is given. They are basic needs of humanity we expect every person be provide.

It is just for a blogger to speak her mind about the government, because she has the right to speak freely.

It is just for a man to attend the religious ceremony of his choosing, because he has the right to determine his own belief system.

It is just for the man of an ethnic minority to pursue the career of his choosing, because he, like those of the majority, have the right to hope and happiness.

This merit and rights based understanding of justice serves our culture well until we cannot decide what is a right, what is not a right, and what must be earned.

Is marriage a right? If so, then preventing people from becoming married, regardless of their gender, is unjust.

Is computer ownership a right or a privilege? One could argue that a computer is basic necessity in our society for success and happiness. For someone to not have one then, because they were born into poverty, would limit their ability to pursue their desired future. It would thus be unjust for only the teens of wealthy parents to have computers. It is just now, it is fair today that every child in school have access to a computer. This was not a justice issue twenty, fifteen, even ten years ago. As our understanding of what we deserve as a right changes, so must what we consider to be just.

Injustice occurs in our cultural understanding when an individual’s rights are hindered or a person receives a status they do not deserve.

It is unjust that the child who grows up in poverty goes to bed hungry.

It is unjust that the woman who works as hard as her male counterparts does not receive the same salary.

It is unjust when a man walks into a bank and takes what he did not earn.

We are angry when the bankers of Wall Street profit while others suffer. It isn’t fair. It is unjust that they have rigged the game so they never lose and we believe they should be punished.

When we find someone profiting from injustice, we punish them. This punishment reestablishes the status quo and serves as a deterrent to others who might seek to profit in unjust ways.

In summary, contemporary culture defines justice as “each person getting what he or she deserves” either through merit or basic human rights. Injustice must be punished to restore the status quo.

This cultural understanding of justice is radically different than Biblical Justice.

Biblical Justice is “doing unto others as you would have them do to you.”

In Biblical Justice each person lives sacrificially for the betterment of his neighbor.

This justice does not have the needs of the individual at its core. It does not stand on the pillars of merit and rights. Rather, this justice is about the success of the community. It demands the individual put himself aside and instead seek what is best for those around him. It requires of practitioners an empathetic eye and a compassionate heart.

Injustice occurs when someone misuses power for personal gain.

Injustice is present when one is made low so another might be elevated.

Injustice happens when one person or a group of people are subjugated so another person or group might advance.

I’ve found that when I read passages in the Bible with my contemporary understanding of justice, everything is thrown out of whack and God does not make sense.

This week I will begin examining passages of scripture in which an understanding of Biblical Justice is critical for understanding the story because contemporary justice mucks it all up.

Stay tuned.

One thought on “Justice: Opening Thoughts

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.